Select A Puppy, Inc. (Middletown Township, New Jersey)

  • 1839 NJ-35, Middletown Township, NJ 07748
  • +1 732-706-7600
  • Rated 4.8/5 with 1882 verified reviews.
  • Website
  • Monday: 11 AM-8 PM
  • Tuesday: 11 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday: 11 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday: 11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday: 11 AM-8 PM
  • Saturday: 11 AM-5 PM
  • Sunday: 11 AM-5 PM

Select A Puppy, Inc. Customer Reviews Summary

We’ve analyzed all available reviews for this breeder and summarized our findings below for your convenience!

Customers have had mixed experiences with this golden retriever breeder. Some customers had a positive experience, mentioning that the staff was helpful and informative.

They also appreciated the clean facilities and the opportunity to bond with the puppies before making a decision. On the other hand, there were negative reviews mentioning high prices and concerns about the health of the puppies.

One customer had to return their puppy because it was unfit for sale and had a difficult time with the process. Another customer mentioned that the breeder gave vague pricing information and ended up being charged an astronomical amount for their puppy.

Overall, it is recommended that potential customers do their research, read reviews, and ask about the breeder's track record before purchasing a puppy from this breeder.

Select A Puppy, Inc. Reviews

We’ve compiled a list of the most helpful reviews for this breeder below. We’ve included both positive and negative (if applicable) reviews to give you a better idea of the type of breeder you’re considering.


Emalie Drudy

My family and i were looking to get a puppy for the first time, we came to select a puppy and instantly fell in love with our beagle boy marley. Only potential downside is that it is a bit pricey but to us it was so worth it, we could not imagine our lives without him. The staff give you plenty of time to bond with the puppy before making a decision and they are highly informative. Thank you!!


April Ricco

We highly recommend select a puppy. My husband and I had to put our Maltipoo of 15 years down. We were crushed. We missed our boy Rocky so much we didn’t know how to process the hurt. We went to select a puppy and spoke with Ryan and the team. They were so helpful throughout our emotional ordeal and found us the perfect puppy, like promised. We are so thankful for our new Maltipoo RJaye. We want to personally thank Ryan for all the updates throughout the process. We now have a precious baby boy. He is such a blessing to watch his personality grow everyday. Thank you all from the bottom of our hearts


John Vitug

We weren’t planning coming home with a puppy today but when you find one and it just clicks, you find a way to go against the plan. We had an excellent experience meeting our new pup from the cleanliness of the facilities to the helpful service. Matty was a gem throughout the process and really worked with our family to find the right pup that met our family’s needs. Really happy to bring Ahsoka into our family and her forever home!


Michael Mills

This review has taken me a while to write. I purchased a puppy back in 2022 from select a puppy. The place was nice and clean and I instantly fell in love with a beautiful puppy. Earlier that day before I arrived i inquired about the price range of the puppies at their establishment. The woman over the phone was vague on the prices and said they range from anywhere 400 and up. A man was showing me the puppy and before I could find out the price he asked me if I wanted it to start the paperwork. He said he was unsure of the price as he “has to scan the puppies microchip to find out”. The price I have spent on my beautiful pup is astonishing. I am young and in my twenties so me being naive I bought the puppy. Now I am stuck paying a huge interest rate loan. All and all the puppies are well taken care of but they will try charge you an astronomical amount for their pups. I will definitely never purchase a puppy from this establishment let alone one of these establishments again.


Diane Boyd

We initially had a great experience, the place appeared extremely clean, the staff was extremely kind, knowledgeable and helpful. There was a great story regarding the breeder and how they personally go to these places to ensure the places are reputable. The price was more than we expected to pay but we did become a victim of falling in love and welcomed our new addition to our family. Unfortunately within a few days of purchase our pet was diagnosed with an ear infection, tape worm, giardia, and pneumonia. We are heartbroken that we were sold a dog that is unfit for sale. We are currently pursuing a claim to cover the medical expenses and praying we do not have to experience losing another pet. Buyer beware do your research, read reviews, verify the so called breeder, ask how many pets have beed deemed unfit for sale. My hope is other families can be saved from incuring this emotional and financial trama from purchasing a pet from this establishment.


Kevin S

When we walked in, we were very impressed. The place smelled so clean, it looked clean, and the staff was very welcoming and pleasant. Although the price was extremely high, we went with the purchase because of how quickly we fell in love with our puppy. The original 5 star review was honest, but also came with a free cheap toy if we did it before we left the store. We went through all the paperwork and did all our post purchase vet visits in a timely manner and unfortunately, the puppy was unfit for sale and we had to make a decision to return him. We were put through so much and they did not make this extremely upsetting process easy at all. They basically tried to buy time to get around the dates on their contract, and we were told “I’m not taking that puppy back”. Okay big shot, tell that to my attorney. I contacted my attorney, the attorney contacted select a puppy, and I quickly recieved the nicest phone call from select a puppy to rectify the situation. Everything worked out in the end, but all this place cares about is money, and has no care for peoples feelings. I DO NOT recommend this place. Save yourself the pain and avoid them, unless you want to roll the dice on a healthy puppy. Interest rates are extremely high as well. I don’t like giving these bad reviews, but I don’t want anyone to go through the dragged out pain my family and I went through.