Prospect Hill Labrador Retrievers (Wallkill, New York)

  • 122 Prospect Hill Rd, Wallkill, NY 12589
  • +1 845-564-8094
  • Rated 4.7/5 with 24 verified reviews.
  • Website
  • Monday: 9 AM-5 PM
  • Tuesday: 9 AM-5 PM
  • Wednesday: 9 AM-5 PM
  • Thursday: 9 AM-5 PM
  • Friday: 9 AM-5 PM
  • Saturday: 9 AM-5 PM
  • Sunday: 9 AM-5 PM

Prospect Hill Labrador Retrievers Customer Reviews Summary

We’ve analyzed all available reviews for this breeder and summarized our findings below for your convenience!

Prospect Hill is praised for their healthy, smart, and well-bred dogs. Customers have been impressed with the intelligence and trainability of their puppies.

The breeder, Tom, is commended for his helpfulness and assistance during the dog buying process. Their dogs are described as beautiful, well-cared for, and having a strong drive.

However, there are a few negative points mentioned. One customer had an issue with the pricing and contract, while another expressed disappointment over not receiving pedigree papers.

Additionally, there was a situation where a customer's preferred color and gender were not available as expected. Overall, customers are satisfied with their puppies and would consider buying from Prospect Hill again in the future.

Prospect Hill Labrador Retrievers Reviews

We’ve compiled a list of the most helpful reviews for this breeder below. We’ve included both positive and negative (if applicable) reviews to give you a better idea of the type of breeder you’re considering.


Howard John Carswell

Prospect Hill has healthy smart dogs we have two that we purchased from Tom. Awesome family members now living at the beach that would also make a great working dog there instincts are strong. I would not hesitate to get another dog but my wife would kill me.


Brad Mills

We are extremely happy with our male chocolate lab from Prospect Hill Labrador Retrievers! We took him home in September 2021, and have all great things to say. Our veterinarian has said more than once that he is an extremely smart, healthy, and well bred lab! Thank you very much to Tom for all of the help!


Gary Horblitt

We have had him since March. Best dog buying experience ever. Great dog! Great with kids. My vet was very impressed with him from his first visit. Extremely bright and easily trainable. He was well worth the wait. Thanks to Tom and Robin


Liam Mullaney

I bought a pup in may of 2021, I can say already at 10 weeks I can already see that the dog has a strong desire to hunt, retrieve and learn. My puppy is learning so fast and it comes very natural to him, he is very sweet and has great focus. That being said I put a deposit on a yellow female and I was supposed to have third pick, I was contacted last minute to pick up my puppy immediately and he claimed he was “trying to call me for weeks” when we had been emailing each other the whole time. When I arrived he has sold all the yellow females and only had two yellow males left and “didn’t notice they were males when we spoke that day before. All and all I am very happy with my puppy and plan on buying another from them down the road. Blizzard was the dad and jasmine was the mom.


Renee Hackett

Tom not home


Matthew Gooding

Pups were advertised at $1,500 total, including $500 deposit. After I mailed my deposit, the breeder, Tom, sent me a contract indicating the price of pup would be $2,500.

The contact also stipulates the dog be fed NuVet supplements or the breeders health guarantee is void. Do a search on NuVet and its practices and form your own opinion.

As of now, pups do not come with pedigree papers. I was okay with this provided I was shown the parents pedigree papers. I never saw the papers.

I am cancelling my deposit.

Dogs were beautiful and appeared to be well-cared for when I met them. Intelligent, good drive